Secondary Market | Cards and Sealed Releases

Hammy earns from qualifying purchases through these eBay links. You buy on eBay from the listed seller.

Format: Single cards ×Grade: 9.5 ×Grading company: BGS ×Serial numbered: Yes ×

Graded card filters

Clear filters

Choose your filters, then apply them together.

Shipping, seller & location

41 eBay matches

Last successful check Sep 14, 2026, 5:23 PM PT

These are saved results; price and availability may have changed. Use Search or Apply filters to check for an update.

Single card · Graded

Topps 2012 Chrome Doug Martin Rookie Autograph Serial Numbered BGS 9.5 #147

$28Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: delaware_card_connection · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2012
Rookie: Yes
Autograph: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Lionel Messi BGS 9.5 (BGS 10 did 150$) numbered!!

$99.98Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: cla.brcl.wacqnc6 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Donruss Elite 2011 Cam Newton Rookie #115 Serial Numbered BGS 9.5 Football Card

$139.99Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: pekapit · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Donruss
Year / season: 2011
Sport: Football
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2025 Topps Series 1 Ted Williams 1990 NNOF No Name Serial Numbered 1/35 BGS 9.5

$1,299.99Last asking price

Free shipping · before tax

Seller: anastasias_collectibles_disney · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 1
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Topps 2025 Now Draft Cooper Flagg #D1 Rookie Serial Numbered 1st Pick BGS 9.5

$51.99Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: chumzcardz · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2025
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Fleer 2001 Authority #117 LaMont Jordan New York Jets Serial Numbered BGS 9.5

$5Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: ironpeakmarket · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Fleer
Year / season: 2001
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2011 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Andrew Luck RC Serial Numbered /99 BGS 9.5

$295Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: cardscomicscollectibles · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Upper Deck
Year / season: 2011
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Jose Altuve Card 2020 Topps Relic Autographs (serial numbered 1 of 1) BGS 9.5

$1,000Last asking price

Shipping from $3 · before tax

Seller: superiorsportsinvestments · 99.9% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2020
Patch / memorabilia: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 1
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

🔥🏀2025 TOPPS CHROME SAPPHIRE BLACK JALEN WILLIAMS NUMBERED /10 BGS 9.5🤩

$425Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: pitcher432 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2025
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Rob Gronkowski 2010 Limited #8 Initial Steps Rookie Auto Numbered /99 BGS 9.5

$599.98Last asking price

Shipping from $5.99 · before tax

Seller: romanrefractor · 100.0% positive

Card details

Year / season: 2010
Rookie: Yes
Autograph: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2019 Leaf Metal Draft Green Gavin Lux Autographed BGS 9.5 Serial Numbered 3/10

$150Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: jef_179397 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Leaf
Year / season: 2019
Autograph: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 3
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2025 TOPPS NOW #577 AARON JUDGE - NUMBERED 3/10 BGS 9.5 POP 1 #3 MVPs Sick

$900Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: sportsphilanthropist · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2025
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 3
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

$2014 Bowman Chrome Cesar Puello Red Refractor Auto BGS 9.5 Numbered 3/5$

Single card · Graded

2014 Bowman Chrome Cesar Puello Red Refractor Auto BGS 9.5 Numbered 3/5

$44.99Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: mazdarotaryjoy · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Bowman
Year / season: 2014
Autograph: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 3
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2019 Bowman GREEN Juan Soto /99 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT #92 Numbered SP Graded Slab

$175.79Last asking price

Free shipping · before tax

Seller: okcards76 · 99.9% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Bowman
Year / season: 2019
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2024 Topps Chrome Mcdonalds AA- Liv McGill Rookie Numbered #'d /35 #69 BGS 9.5

$199.99Last asking price

Shipping from $13 · before tax

Seller: gamethecollector · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2024
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

BGS 9.5 2019-20 PANINI /249 RC PRIZM DRAFT PICKS ZION WILLIAMSON NUMBERED #1

$315Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: paulmarci10 · 99.8% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Panini
Year / season: 2019-20
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

BGS 9.5 2003-04 Fleer Ultra Lucky 13 Darko Milicic #172 RC Un-Numbered POP 5

$22.95Last asking price

Free shipping · before tax

Seller: rmcards4u · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Fleer
Year / season: 2003-04
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2015 Dynasty Numbered to 5/5 Tom Glavine BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Patch Auto HOF 00em

$856.09Last asking price

Shipping from $4.99 · before tax

Seller: comc_consignment · 99.5% positive

Card details

Year / season: 2015
Autograph: Yes
Patch / memorabilia: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 5
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2011 Press Pass Legends Platinum BO JACKSON True numbered 1/1 One of One BGS 9.5

$8,000Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: coolcardlife · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Press Pass
Year / season: 2011
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 1
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2019-20 Select Tie-Dye Anthony Davis numbered to 25 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Prizm

$399.99Last asking price

Free shipping · before tax

Seller: kpacards90 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Year / season: 2019-20
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 25
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2020 TOPPS NOW #480 LOS ANGELES DODGERS NUMBERED /25 PARALLEL BGS 9.5 POP 1

$200Last asking price

Shipping from $8 · before tax

Seller: sportsphilanthropist · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Topps
Year / season: 2020
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

Marco Rossi Artifacts Materials Horizontal Numbered /399 Graded BGS 9.5 Gem Mint

$40Last asking price

Shipping from $5.25 · before tax

Seller: cocarr-99 · 99.8% positive

Card details

Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2014-15 Select Rookie Signatures MARCUS SMART 36/275 JERSEY NUMBERED BGS 9.5/10!

$309.99Last asking price

Shipping from $5.50 · before tax

Seller: bsereni12 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Year / season: 2014-15
Rookie: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 275
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2004 Fleer Authentix Rookies ‘Non-Numbered’ Eli Manning #103 Rookie RC, BGS 9.5

$350Last asking price

Shipping from $5 · before tax

Seller: 1018lively · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Fleer
Year / season: 2004
Rookie: Yes
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Single card · Graded

2018 Donruss Optic TRAE YOUNG Choice Red Rookie JERSEY Numbered 11/88 BGS 9.5!

$1,250Last asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: alan4181 · 100.0% positive

Card details

Manufacturer: Donruss
Year / season: 2018
Rookie: Yes
Serial numbered: Yes
Serial-number range: 11
Graded / raw: Graded
Grading company: BGS
Grade: 9.5

Check on eBay

Continue this search on eBay ↗

From Hammy’s guides

Featured in Hammy’s guides

Hammy earns from qualifying purchases through these eBay links. Buy on eBay from the seller shown in each listing.

2018 Topps Update #US1 Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 ROOKIE RC

Single card

2018 Topps Update Ohtani #US1 PSA 10

2018 Topps Update #US1 Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 ROOKIE RC

Type: Sports Trading Card
Season: 2018
Card Number: US1
Set: 2018 Topps Update
Grade: 10
Professional Grader: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)

$627Asking price

Shipping from $16 · before tax

Seller: collectiblexchange

Graded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Five Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards Worth Building a Collection Around

2018 BOWMAN CHROME #1 SHOHEI OHTANI PSA 10

Single card

2018 Bowman Chrome Ohtani #1 PSA 10

2018 BOWMAN CHROME #1 SHOHEI OHTANI PSA 10

Type: Sports Trading Card
Set: 2018 BOWMAN CHROME
Grade: 10
Professional Grader: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
Card Number: 1
Season: 2018

$6,999Asking price

Shipping from $5.99 · before tax

Seller: psa

Graded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Five Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards Worth Building a Collection Around

2018 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR #150 SHOHEI OHTANI ROOKIE RC PSA 10

Single card

2018 Topps Chrome Ohtani Refractor PSA 10

2018 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR #150 SHOHEI OHTANI ROOKIE RC PSA 10

Set: 2018 TOPPS CHROME
Grade: 10
Type: Sports Trading Card
Parallel/Variety: REFRACTOR
Professional Grader: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
Card Number: 150
Season: 2018

$7,000Asking price

Shipping from $5.99 · before tax

Seller: psa

Graded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Five Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards Worth Building a Collection Around

2018 Topps Chrome - Rookie Autographs Shohei Ohtani #RA-SO (AU, RC)

Single card

2018 Topps Chrome Ohtani rookie autograph PSA 10

2018 Topps Chrome - Rookie Autographs Shohei Ohtani #RA-SO (AU, RC)

Type: Sports Trading Card
Set: 2018 Topps Chrome
Parallel/Variety: [Base]
Card Number: RA-SO
Season: 2018
Professional Grader: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
Grade: 10

$85,000Asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: klm_6820

Graded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Five Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards Worth Building a Collection Around

2025-26 Topps Flagship Diamante Cooper Flagg RC Dallas Mavericks #201

Single card

Cooper Flagg Topps Diamante

2025-26 Topps Flagship Diamante Cooper Flagg RC Dallas Mavericks #201

Set: Topps Flagship Diamante
Card Number: 201
Type: Sports Trading Card
Season: 2025

$49.19Asking price

Shipping from $5.99 · before tax

Seller: ml_sports_cards_plus

Ungraded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Cooper Flagg Rookie Cards: Five Levels, From $50 to a 1/1 Grail

2025-26 Topps - Cooper Flagg #201 Purple Holofoil /250 Rookie Mavericks

Single card

Cooper Flagg Topps Purple Holofoil /250

2025-26 Topps - Cooper Flagg #201 Purple Holofoil /250 Rookie Mavericks

Type: Sports Trading Card
Set: 2025-26 Topps
Parallel/Variety: Purple Holofoil
Card Number: 201
Season: 2025-26

$249.99Asking price

Shipping shown on eBay · before tax

Seller: mintedbymiller

Ungraded

Last checked Sep 14, 2026, 10:15 PM PT

View on eBay

Read Hammy’s guide: Cooper Flagg Rookie Cards: Five Levels, From $50 to a 1/1 Grail

41 eBay matches

Topps 2012 Chrome Doug Martin Rookie Autograph Serial Numbered BGS 9.5 #147

Lionel Messi BGS 9.5 (BGS 10 did 150$) numbered!!

Donruss Elite 2011 Cam Newton Rookie #115 Serial Numbered BGS 9.5 Football Card

2025 Topps Series 1 Ted Williams 1990 NNOF No Name Serial Numbered 1/35 BGS 9.5

Topps 2025 Now Draft Cooper Flagg #D1 Rookie Serial Numbered 1st Pick BGS 9.5

Fleer 2001 Authority #117 LaMont Jordan New York Jets Serial Numbered BGS 9.5

2011 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Andrew Luck RC Serial Numbered /99 BGS 9.5

Jose Altuve Card 2020 Topps Relic Autographs (serial numbered 1 of 1) BGS 9.5

🔥🏀2025 TOPPS CHROME SAPPHIRE BLACK JALEN WILLIAMS NUMBERED /10 BGS 9.5🤩

Rob Gronkowski 2010 Limited #8 *Initial Steps* Rookie Auto Numbered /99 BGS 9.5

2019 Leaf Metal Draft Green Gavin Lux Autographed BGS 9.5 Serial Numbered 3/10

2025 TOPPS NOW #577 AARON JUDGE - NUMBERED 3/10 BGS 9.5 POP 1 #3 MVPs Sick

2014 Bowman Chrome Cesar Puello Red Refractor Auto BGS 9.5 Numbered 3/5

2019 Bowman GREEN Juan Soto /99 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT #92 Numbered SP Graded Slab

2024 Topps Chrome Mcdonalds AA- Liv McGill Rookie Numbered #'d /35 #69 BGS 9.5

BGS 9.5 2019-20 PANINI /249 RC PRIZM DRAFT PICKS ZION WILLIAMSON NUMBERED #1

BGS 9.5 2003-04 Fleer Ultra Lucky 13 Darko Milicic #172 RC Un-Numbered POP 5

2015 Dynasty Numbered to 5/5 Tom Glavine BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Patch Auto HOF 00em

2011 Press Pass Legends Platinum BO JACKSON True numbered 1/1 One of One BGS 9.5

2019-20 Select Tie-Dye Anthony Davis numbered to 25 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Prizm

2020 TOPPS NOW #480 LOS ANGELES DODGERS NUMBERED /25 PARALLEL BGS 9.5 POP 1

Marco Rossi Artifacts Materials Horizontal Numbered /399 Graded BGS 9.5 Gem Mint

2014-15 Select Rookie Signatures MARCUS SMART 36/275 JERSEY NUMBERED BGS 9.5/10!

2004 Fleer Authentix Rookies ‘Non-Numbered’ Eli Manning #103 Rookie RC, BGS 9.5

2018 Donruss Optic TRAE YOUNG Choice Red Rookie JERSEY Numbered 11/88 BGS 9.5!

Featured in Hammy’s guides

2018 Topps Update Ohtani #US1 PSA 10

2018 Bowman Chrome Ohtani #1 PSA 10

2018 Topps Chrome Ohtani Refractor PSA 10

2018 Topps Chrome Ohtani rookie autograph PSA 10

Cooper Flagg Topps Diamante

Cooper Flagg Topps Purple Holofoil /250

Rob Gronkowski 2010 Limited #8 Initial Steps Rookie Auto Numbered /99 BGS 9.5